There should be a 20 cent levy on shopping bags at supermarkets?


On average, everyone agrees with significant nonconsensus between 55 voters.

Disagree
 
Agree

Please read the comments from other voters below, then scroll down make your decision. Do you agree or disagree with the following statement?

There should be a 20 cent levy on shopping bags at supermarkets

You need to register a voting profile or login before you can vote.


Reasons To Disagree

This cost will only be passed on to the consumer and for many the price of groceries is high enough. I agree that we should be using reusable bags. More positive reasons need to be offerd to use reusable bags rather than trying to punish some one. Positive incentives are always the best way to go, punishment should always be a last resort.

25 January 2007

The cost of bags would simply be absorbed in teh overall proce of products and it is teh consumer that needs to change its activities, not the retailer. If the costs can be seperated and identified to the consumer during payment then there may be a chance however the cost must be high enough to affect behaviour thus effectively a penalty.

1 April 2007

A socialist question!

28 October 2007

Another rise?

4 July 2008

WHY? WHAT FOR? TAX _ TAX _ TAX!!! Virtually every question so far has been a suggestion to impose a tax or a cost. The greenies - if they had their way - would ensure that nobody had any money left in their pocket to do anything.

22 December 2009

Kiwis should learn to look after our environment. caring for the environment should not be an excuse for supermarkets to profit

28 May 2011

Paying for bags is stupid and unnecessary...what if the bag breaks? We need to pay another 20c to replace it.. Not necessary..

20 May 2013

people get boxes for free and dumb them why not charge them. I reuse my plastic bag several times too.

13 January 2014

 

Reasons To Agree

It would be great to see NZ do something to back up its clean green image and would be a solid start to tackling the threat of climate change. Check out this site for further info: www.bagtax.org.nz

26 January 2007

The effect in Ireland was that 90% of shopping bags disappeared... 20 cents spread across 10 items in a bag, is only going to increase the spend by approximately 2cents per item. What i can't understand is why checkout operators put 3 litre orange juice bottles in their own bags.. they don't really need bags... All in all tho, its the plastic used in packaging that is more harmful that the plastic bags themselves... In Netherlands the government mandated that shops must pay about $1 for returned bottles... now this cost was only passed on to the customer once, however it gave a very good incentive to everyone to recycle.

19 February 2007

only if the "supermarket" has to pay for them, so it would force them to use (hopefully) strong paper or reusable bags instead.

24 March 2007

yep, if one had to pay for all those free plastic bags, we would all be buying our calico ones en mass and plastic bags would disapear for ever - never had them when I was grown up and we managed

27 April 2007

plastic shopping bags, not reusable ones

14 June 2007

I use boxes anyway

12 October 2007

Better yet, ban them. I use re-usable bags. So should everyone else.

10 October 2010

Yes, then it makes people think. It works for pak'n'save. Also introduce recycled paper-bags. there is no limit to how many times you can recycle paper.

11 May 2011

I personally think that we should just completely ban shopping bags altogether point.

21 May 2017

Reasons for Remain Neutral

No reasons have yet been given to remain neutral.

My View

You can make your comments once you have voted.

You need to register a voting profile or login before you can vote.

Back to all voting categories or
Back to "Environment"

Please tell all your friends to come and vote, and please link to our website if you can.

We use Website World Free Website Builder to easily update our website ourselves
and provide you with this voting software.