Expensive surgical operations should be denied to the very elderly where they are not life critical?


On average, everyone disagrees with nonconsensus between 243 voters.

Disagree
 
Agree

Please read the comments from other voters below, then scroll down make your decision. Do you agree or disagree with the following statement?

Expensive surgical operations should be denied to the very elderly where they are not life critical

You need to register a voting profile or login before you can vote.


Reasons To Disagree

Quality of life is as important in elder ages as in youth.

11 January 2006

Who would be responsible for this decision. I am 60 nad would hate to have a hospital person make such a huge choice for me

1 April 2006

Depends on Quality Years of Life afforded by such treatment. QualYs are a statistical analysis tool that can be used to make this policy decision fairly.

20 April 2006

Third World thinking! Additionally, these people have probably paid more tax dollars over their lifetimes than younger people, so they should be even more entitled to medical care.

20 May 2006

Euthinasia should be a legalised choice/option - even elderly people feel pain and discomfort and we all know that we cannot live forever at this level of our consciousness - so ones humanity should be respected at every cycle of ones life

27 April 2007

not denied but they should be last on the list

1 May 2008

Treated equal??

4 July 2008

All effort should be made to have an elderly person stay indepent and mobile for as long as possible.That means, eye,knee and hip operations are very much in priority.

5 October 2008

These people have paid taxes, fought wars for our liberty, bought us Xmas prsesnts when we were kids. It is an honour to look after our elders.

17 July 2009

 

Reasons To Agree

It is abhorrent that people be forced to pay for state medical insurance, then the state decide their Qual.O.Life does not warrant state expenditure.

13 December 2007

Regretably - yes! We cannot afford state of the art treatment for everybody regardless of cost. There HAS to be a rational rationing system clearly spelled out.

17 February 2008

I semi agree, its their choice whether or not they want to do surgery... BUT its a waste of resources to be using on the elderly. No offence :)

16 February 2009

I'm an oldie, and I agree. Even if they ARE life critical. You gotta go sometimne.

10 October 2010

Criteria for this must be very specific, and appeals must be allowed.

2 December 2012

Reasons for Remain Neutral

No reasons have yet been given to remain neutral.

My View

You can make your comments once you have voted.

You need to register a voting profile or login before you can vote.

Back to all voting categories or
Back to "Health"

Please tell all your friends to come and vote, and please link to our website if you can.

We use Website World Free Website Builder to easily update our website ourselves
and provide you with this voting software.