Military service should be compulsory for those on unemployment benefits longer than 6 months.?
On average, everyone disagrees with significant nonconsensus between 277 voters.
Please read the comments from other voters below, then scroll down make your decision. Do you agree or disagree with the following statement?
Military service should be compulsory for those on unemployment benefits longer than 6 months.
Reasons To Disagree
This would better suit malignant individuals and petty criminals rather than anyone on a benefit
25 March 2006
some people have disabitys
28 November 2006
Any form of compulsory military training is out of the question in a free country.
10 February 2007
why - so we can send the 'duds' to fight other peoples wars? hardly fair.
1 October 2007
NO NO NO NO NO Don't let your spite towards those who "leech" your oh so hard earned tax dollars make you think this is a good idea. The military needs strong, fit, mentally capable and motivated people. New Zealand has an all volunteer military for a reason - those who want to be there make the best soldiers/sailors/airmen.
21 December 2007
While it may do something for some individuals it imposes a load on defense services who ought to be doing their own jobs.
17 February 2008
my mum is rather overweight has 3 kids at home and one has a disablilty she also is very sick and finds it hard to just look after her kids i think military would kill her
31 May 2008
No cause than you will end up with people who have no clue about military working for the military and thats just stupid
21 August 2008
I think some kind of compulsory military training (I'm ex-Airforce) would work for young offenders. However having some adult, dread-locked, beer gutted, tattooed from neck to ankle, dole bludger rolling through a forest armed with an IW Steyer (standard issue auto rifle) is a recipe for disaster.
17 July 2009
some of the people on the dole, have been declined from joining the military because they do not want to risk it medically. Why should then the military who said they don't want to risk it medically, then be force to have people with pre-existing health condition unsafe for the military, its putting unnecessary people lives at risk.
27 February 2015
Reasons To Agree
if you choose to sit on a benefit then yes
20 March 2006
It certainly does change people and provides them with a purpose and self discipline. I think it is an excellent idea!
25 March 2007
They should do something, or otherwise they are getting paid to do nothing, and what better way to do it than helping out our country
10 December 2011
Reasons for Remain Neutral
great idea, but it would be better to pay voulanteers on low incomes to go and to Peace corps style community work in the pacific islands, for example.
A nice idea... but do we have the resources to train people this way? and does the military want this responsibility? Also if compulsory military service was required how long would the said service be?
Change it to between 18 to 25 get 1 whole year to get a job or do Military service required.
You can make your comments once you have voted.